The Path to Perfect Pharmaceutical Batch Production
By 
Emmeline Yuen-O'Sullivan
06-Oct-21
TQS Pharma Batch

Businesses within the pharmaceutical and life sciences sector must continuously ensure batch quality is maintained at the highest standards. After all, quality is the most critical metric in pharmaceutical manufacturing, nothing is more important than protecting patient health. However, the impact doesn’t go without also reaching bottom-lines and profitability. The numbers speak for themselves: The cost of a single batch deviation can range from $20,000 to $1M per batch, depending on the product.

Tight control of processes, inputs, and other variables is a necessity for successful pharmaceutical manufacturing. Traditionally, there have not been effective ways of looking at historical and time-series data to investigate deviations and variability besides spending painfully tedious hours of subject matter expert (SME) time in spreadsheets. Engineers look to create process parameter profiles to serve as guides for reducing process variability and increasing yield for all future batch development—also known as the “golden profile”.

But there are two problems with this. First, creating golden batch profiles repeatedly requires many hours spent manually sifting through years of data or delayed lab results that make it difficult to optimize process inputs to control the batch yield. And second, out-of-tolerance events will still occur, regardless of applying diligence in controlling the Critical Process Parameters (CPPs) of a recipe, as measured by a group of Critical Quality Attributes (CQAs). Often, it becomes clear the number of variables and the cause-and-effect relationships connecting these two aspects are more complex than originally assumed.

Find Your “Golden Batch”—Efficiently

The data is there. But it’s time to efficiently analyze it. The method of manually extracting production data from historians and various repositories within an industrial control system and creating graphs in Excel is outdated and doesn’t solve the whole puzzle of accurately finding the relationships mentioned above. There are many limitations on how a spreadsheet can actually be applied to understand complex process variability and provide actionable insights. Leading pharmaceutical companies have made the transition to advanced analytics to find their perfect batch parameters.

Applying Advanced Analytics to Make Data-Backed Decisions

The most efficient and intuitive way to lead your team to golden batch discovery and application is through advanced analytics. Applying the technology eliminates all manual work in spreadsheets and automatically cleanses, contextualizes, aggregates, and analyzes your process data in near real-time. It makes the manual connections that your engineers won’t have to—freeing up their time to apply the analysis to your process parameters and production methods to see improvements in quality and performance.

Seeq, the leading provider of advanced analytics, can be scaled applied across your entire organization, running on standard office computers and communicating directly with historians to quickly extract data and present results.

A Behind-the-Scenes Look

To visualize the application in action and for this specific business issue, assume you’re examining a production process with six CPPs connected to a single unit procedure. Using historical data from ideal batches with acceptable specifications on all CQAs, advanced analytics enables you to simply and easily graph these six variables from all the previous unit procedures. Curves representing performance from historical CPPs can then be superimposed on top of each other using identical scales to reveal new insights within the application.

It’s immediately seen if the curves tend to form a tight group, or if they are spread out, showing different values at various times. Seeq can easily aggregate these curves without the need for complex formulas or macros to establish an ideal profile for each CPP. Engineers can replicate this procedure, resulting in an updated reference profile and boundary for every variable. In the end, this process reveals new opportunities for process optimization.

In the screenshot below, Seeq’s advanced analytics is analyzing the cell culture process in an upstream biopharmaceutical manufacturer that is producing Penicillin. The technology is used to create a model for Penicillin concentration based on historical batches to find the CPPs that will produce the ideal batch. This model can then be deployed on future batches with golden profiles for CPPs to effectively track deviations and prevent them from occurring.

In another example, a leading pharmaceutical manufacturer saved millions of dollars by gaining the ability to rapidly identify and analyze root cause analysis of abnormal batches via similar modeling techniques in Seeq. The team reduced the number of out-of-specification batches by adjusting process parameters during the batch and saved on the reduction of wasted energy and materials.

Additionally, Bristol-Meyers Squibb utilizes modern technologies, including advanced analytics, to capture the specialized knowledge needed to test the uniformity of their column packing processes. Seeq is deployed to rapidly identify the data of interest for conductivity testing to calculate asymmetry, summarize data, and plot the curves for verification by their SMEs. The entire team is empowered to operationalize their analytics by calculating a CPP and distributing it across the entire enterprise, providing reliable and fast insight as to when a column was packed correctly. In turn, this prevents product losses, product quality issues, and even complete losses of a batch.

Developing and deploying an online predictive model of pharmaceutical product quality and yield can additionally aid in fault detection and enable rapid root cause analysis, helping to ensure quality standards are maintained with every batch.

Across multiple use cases, one thing is clear—advanced analytics is the future of trusting batch quality to the highest extent for pharmaceutical and life sciences manufacturing. Combining the latest initiatives in digital transformation, machine learning, and Industry 4.0, it’s the technology that empowers your engineers to their fullest potential in making data-driven decisions to tremendously improve operations.

Applying Advanced Analytics to Your Operation

Are you ready to increase your batch quality and yield by incorporating seamless golden batch development cycles and application with advanced analytics? Make sure to watch this webinar from Seeq for insight on additional ways that advanced analytics can be used to capture knowledge from all parts of the product evolution cycle—from laboratory process design and development through scale-up and commercial manufacturing.

If you’re looking to see the technology live and in action, schedule a demo of the technology here.

© All rights reserved.